DAVID BIANCULLI

Founder / Editor

ERIC GOULD

Associate Editor

LINDA DONOVAN

Assistant Editor

Contributors

ALEX STRACHAN

MIKE HUGHES

GARY EDGERTON

ROGER CATLIN

KIM AKASS

GERALD JORDAN

MONIQUE NAZARETH

TOM BRINKMOELLER

NOEL HOLSTON

 
 
 
 
 
NBC's 'Hannibal' Exhibits Quick Decline
April 3, 2013  | By Ed Bark  | 7 comments
 

There’s a lot to digest in NBC’s Hannibal, much of it distasteful and, worse yet from a storytelling standpoint, increasingly impossible to swallow.

This becomes more evident as this NBC series — which premieres Thursday, April 4 at 10 p.m. ET — deteriorates from a graphic but promising first episode to a third hour that basically falls apart from any rational credibility standpoint.

Hannibal also gorges itself on the murders and mutilations of mostly young women. It’s become an apparently incurable epidemic on the increasingly desperate Big 4 broadcast networks. And Hannibal, in its fifth hour, presents the stomach-churning sight of a nurse crawling on all fours after having her eyes gouged out. She ends up as a crime scene exhibit, impaled by far too many sharp instruments to count. Guess she got lucky. In Thursday’s premiere, a coed is found on nude display in the great outdoors, perforated by a dozen or more deer antlers on a sacrificial altar of sorts. She’s the 10th of 11 female victims in the first hour alone.

One wasn’t expecting a Good Ship Lollipop. Dr. Hannibal Lecter (played by Mads Mikkelsen this time around) is the now renowned serial-killing cannibal popularized in the Thomas Harris novels and several feature films. So a certain amount of gore is expected if not demanded, even if Lecter isn’t directly responsible for most of the dead bodies piling up in the first five episodes sent to TV critics.

Lecter instead is the Arnold Schwarzenegger-accented psychiatrist brought in to help criminal profiler Will Graham (Hugh Dancy) get a grip on himself. He has the unfortunate — for him at least — ability to see into the psyches of serial killers and put himself in their shoes as they wreak mayhem.

A vivid demonstration of this is right up top in Episode 1, complete with pounding/screeching music and three vertical light bars whenever Will in a sense, “hulks out.” This allows him to personally reenact, in gruesome detail, the murders of an innocent homebound couple. And there’s no scrimping on the fake blood budget.

Insular, anti-social Will also schools cadets at the FBI Academy in Quantico, VA, where he demonstrates the hows and whys of killers. But he’s reluctantly on call to taciturn FBI Behavioral Science Unit head Jack Crawford (Laurence Fishburne in a segue from CSI: Crime Scene Investigation). For starters, Crawford wants to catch whoever’s abducted eight female Minnesota students, seven of them already presumed dead.

“They’re all very Mall of America,” Will says drily. Guess that’s supposed to be funny.

Hannibal in fact is pretty engaging in the first two episodes. Dancy nicely inhabits his tortured soul role and Mikkelsen is interestingly cryptic as well as an accomplished gourmet cook whose guests really have no idea what they’re eating. “Next time bring your wife,” he tells Fishburne’s Crawfrod near the end of Episode 2. “I’d love to have you both for dinner.”

But it all starts tumbling down in Episode 3, with amoral blogger “Freddie” Lounds (Lara Jean Chorostecki) of tattlecrime.com repeatedly gaining laughably easily access to crime scenes and key players.

You think the cops on Fox’s The Following are bad at protecting people? Not compared to these law enforcement types. Even the unhinged brother of one of the deceased is able to easily stroll in and threaten the surviving daughter of a deranged killer father. It then gets even more ludicrous when Lecter manages to intercede and blackmail her. This whole storyline is then abruptly dropped by Episode 4, even though the daughter in question is still presumably suspected of possibly being an accomplice in her father’s foul deeds.

Episode 4 begins with Will walking down a highway in his underwear, with an imagined moose trailing him. In other words he’s increasingly troubled and haunted by gruesome crime scenes and the killings he’d reenacted. Another gross-out double murder is just around the corner, though. Hmm, wonder how the perpetrator eventually managed, all by himself, to … well, never mind. You’ll probably ask the same question when and if you see him in his final state.

Hour 5 includes a guest appearance by Eddie Izzard as the aforementioned nurse-slayer. Housed at the Baltimore State Hospital for the Criminally Insane, where he committed the murder, he’d now also like to take credit for being the vile, still at large Chesapeake Ripper. The episode also includes flashback scenes tied to Crawford’s ill-fated grooming and mentoring of a budding young female FBI profiler.

When not succumbing to over-the-top, ooh-scary mood music, Hannibal takes multiple stabs at being thought-provoking on the subjects of life, death and even the Creator. Lecter and Will have what’s meant to a pithy exchange at the close of Episode 2.

“Killing must feel good to God, too,” Lecter says after Will struggles with feeling oddly exhilarated about blowing away his first bad guy. “He does it all the time. And are we not created in His image?”

“That depends on who you ask,” Will replies.

Lecter: “God is terrific. He dropped a church roof on 34 of his worshippers last Wednesday night in Texas while they sang a hymn.”

Will: “Did God feel good about that?”

Lecter: “He felt powerful.”

If you think about it, that’s a lot of mumbo jumbo disguised as deep-think. Hannibal starts out in stronger shape than that before becoming gratuitous with its carnage and too often ludicrous in getting from A to B. Still, the performances are solid for the most part, with Dancy looking every bit as drained and haunted as Kevin Bacon does on a weekly basis in The Following.

That Fox series has gotten bogged down of late. Even so, it’s still in better shape at present than Hannibal will be by the end of Episode 3. It makes one appreciate Showtime’s Dexter all the more. After seven seasons it’s still got a pulse. And at least Dexter Morgan’s serial killing victims are mostly murderous men who richly deserve being sliced, diced and thrown overboard.

GRADE: C

Read more by Ed Bark at unclebarky.com

 
 
 
 
 
Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 
 Name (required)
 
 Email (required) (will not be published)
 
 Website (optional)
 
IWTDW
Type in the verification word shown on the image.
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: 
7 Comments
 
 
Tom
Not to mension all of the conversations and qoutes that they have stolen directly from the movies, as if they couldn't come up with any "deep qoutes" on their own.
And when I saw the "nurse-killer" escaping custody in an ambulance, I couldn't bear watching any more!
May 29, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
kevin
Caught April 4's episode. If the actors, directors, writers, etc. are supposed to Graham an a-hole and Hannibal a good guy, then I'm not gonna watch and they did their jobs.........Disliked Graham. Found Graham frustrating to root for. Found Hannibal endearing at the end when we see him asleep in the chair and holding teenage girl's hand as she lay recovering in her hospital bed.
Apr 8, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
kevin
Caught April 4's episode. If the actors, directors, writers, etc. are supposed to Graham an a-hole and Hannibal a good guy, then I'm not gonna watch and they did their jobs.........Disliked Graham. Found Graham frustrating to root for. Found Hannibal endearing at the end when we see him asleep in the chair and holding teenage girl's hand as she lay recovering in her hospital bed.
Apr 8, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
kevin
Caught April 4's episode. If the actors, directors, writers, etc. are supposed to Graham an a-hole and Hannibal a good guy, then I'm not gonna watch and they did their jobs.........Disliked Graham. Found Graham frustrating to root for. Found Hannibal endearing at the end when we see him asleep in the chair and holding teenage girl's hand as she lay recovering in her hospital bed.
Apr 8, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
Craig Forshaw
Three things:

(1) Haven't seen 'Hannibal' yet, but it looks and sounds pretty good.

(2) Also, the exchange of dialogue you included there that was "mumbo jumbo" sounds to me more like Will projecting his uncertainty about whether killing is ever justified, and Lecter projecting his certainty that the power it grants is intoxicating. What is doesn't sound like is two men debating theological issues.

(3) In 'Buffy', they explained all the monsters were there because of the Hellmouth. In 'The Following' (which is laughably awful), they explained it by having them all be in a cult. 'Dexter' (which I hate, despite everyone disagreeing with me, and which I maintain survives solely because of a charismatic leading man) doesn't explain why there are so many serial killers in Florida, or how the police department keep promoting people who fail to capture their main suspects because Dexter keeps murdering them? Lecter at least makes sense.
Apr 5, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
Angela
I don't understand why so many TV shows have become so dark and grim. I do like dark shows, as long as they are tastefully done, for instance Breaking Bad fits that category to a T. But the last thing I need is to get inside the mind of a serial-killer, and see lots of dead bodies, blood and gore, with screaming music, and pulsing lights! ( It almost sounds laughable.) And I always intersperse the dark shows with shows that the entire family can watch like Parenthood.

Granted shows like Parenthood are becoming much more difficult to come by in the last few years. But I'm not that desperate that I'd watch this to fill in the spaces.
Thanks for saving me from another hour of worthless TV watching.
Apr 4, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
Donna L Dale
Mikkelsen speaks English with a mild Danish accent, greatly removed from the Schwarzenegger guttural mutilation of the language.
Apr 4, 2013   |  Reply
 
Brad
Did you live/work in St. Louis?
Oct 29, 2013
 
 
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: