Founder / Editor


Associate Editor


Assistant Editor











'The New York Times Presents: The Killing of Breonna Taylor' Examines What Happened Just After Midnight on March 13
September 4, 2020  | By Mike Hughes

In the heated debate over Breonna Taylor's death, David James is in a unique position.

The argument has multiple sides – police, politicians, Blacks, and officials. He happens to fit all of those categories – a Black councilman in Louisville and a former narcotics officer who spent 14 years as a cop.

And now he's key to The New York Times Presents: The Killing of Breonna Taylor, at 10 p.m. Friday (Sept. 4) on FX and Hulu.

This is an comprehensive look – an hour without commercials on Hulu, 81 minutes on FX. It has a brief portrayal of Taylor, 26, described by friends, her mother, and her boyfriend (Kenneth Walker) as an upbeat soul, an emergency medical technician at work, a fun person at home. Then it gets into the case.

Louisville police planned a March 13 narcotics raid on Taylor's ex-boyfriend, Jamarcus Glover, hitting four houses in a drug-scarred area. But they also planned to hit Taylor's apartment in a more-upscale neighborhood because they felt Glover had been stashing drugs there.

It was a big operation, James says, with 70 officers in combinations that hadn't worked together before. And all five were "no-knock" warrants, allowing them to simply break down the door.

James says there are two good choices – no-knock or knock and firmly announce that you're police. "There is not such a thing as 'knock and not-announce.' That is the most dangerous thing you can do," especially with Kentucky's "stand your ground" law.

Police say they announced themselves several times. Neighbors say they heard the knocks, but most say they heard no announcement; one neighbor says he heard one.

And Walker insists he heard none. When the door was being broken, he fired a shot, hitting policeman Jonathan Mattingly in the leg.

Three police – Mattingly, Brett Hankinson, and Myles Cosgrove – responded. "I heard about 20-25 shots," one neighbor says. Adds another: "It sounded like the OK Corral."

Five of the shots hit Taylor, the film says, and she soon died. "It was a war zone in there," says an attorney for her family. No drugs were found in the apartment.

In the aftermath, a string of complaints surfaced about Hankinson. He was fired, partly for "wantonly and blindly" shooting from outside the apartment and partly for other complaints.

The complication: Hankinson fired from a position that made it less likely that his bullets were the ones that hit Taylor.

Now comes the long aftermath. Charges against Walker (for shooting Mattingly) were dropped. Louisville banned no-knock warrants and required body cameras for all drug raids. The FBI and Kentucky's attorney general are digging through ballistics reports to determine whose bullets went where.

The discussion on the fatal raid remains a heated subject in Louisville and nationally. New details on the circumstances continue to be revealed, and The New York Times Presents: The Killing of Breonna Taylor is an excellent way to discover them.

Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 Name (required)
 Email (required) (will not be published)
Type in the verification word shown on the image.