DAVID BIANCULLI

Founder / Editor

ERIC GOULD

Associate Editor

LINDA DONOVAN

Assistant Editor

Contributors

ALEX STRACHAN

MIKE HUGHES

GARY EDGERTON

ROGER CATLIN

KIM AKASS

GERALD JORDAN

TOM BRINKMOELLER

NOEL HOLSTON

 
 
 
 
 
The New 'Roots' Still Has Plenty to Teach Us
May 31, 2016  | By David Hinckley
 

Watching the new Roots, which would be one of the best TV things you could do this week, you’re reminded that in at least one important sense, it’s not about slavery at all.

It’s about how individuals behave in a world where slavery happens to be an accepted institution.

The new Roots, a four-part, eight-hour series that airs Monday-Thursday at 9 p.m. ET on History, Lifetime and A&E wisely follows the lead of the original 1977 production by making us care about the enslaved African, Kunta Kinte (Malachi Kirby, top) and the subsequent generations that finally fulfill his fierce determination to regain their freedom.

It’s tempting to say that in finding that freedom, they also restored their human dignity. But the real point of Roots, in many ways, is that they never lost their dignity.

While Kunta Kinte was degraded, beaten and humiliated, all parts of the slavery package, he never stopped believing he was really a Mandinka warrior.

That’s underscored in the first episode by the older African, Fiddler (Forest Whittaker).

Fiddler is introduced as a black man who has abandoned himself. He seemingly has submitted to the bidding of the “massa,” John Waller (James Purefoy, left), in exchange for a tiny shred of autonomy, meaning his shackles aren’t physical.

After Fiddler is assigned to break Kunta, meaning Fiddler gets the blame if Kunta rebels, Fiddler helps Kunta in a futile escape attempt.

Fiddler, it turns out, is from the “tell ‘em what they want to hear” school. If you know your real name, he tells Kunta, it doesn’t matter what they call you, because “this isn’t your home – this is just a place you have to be.”

The dialogue in Roots is sprinkled with philosophical passages like that, alongside a few lines that might give the viewer pause, like a Mandinka warrior in the mid-18th century saying something will happen “sooner than later.”

No matter. Roots became a phenomenon almost 40 years ago because the Alex Haley book on which it was based was not a documentary on slavery. It dramatized the stories of specific people who were forced – or, on the other side, delighted – to live under its auspices.

The first episode alone contains several extended scenes so brutal they’re hard to watch. Their common moral thread is that the perpetrators of this brutality felt no shame. Rather, they declared their actions were necessary and proper to achieve their legitimate interest: getting maximum production out of this slave for whom, or rather for which, they paid good money.

Nor does Roots pass over the wide range of non-physical cruelties, like knowing your spouse or child could be sold tomorrow to a plantation several states away and you might never see them again.

The beneficiaries of this system are not all painted with the same brush. The cold John Waller has a brother, William (Matthew Goode), who has a streak of sympathy. Just not enough to step in when Kunta’s back is whipped into hamburger by a sadistic overseer.

That overseer, John Waller and others like them are the easy villains here, and certainly the ones on whom the producers encourage us to focus our outrage.

As the roster of these nasty pieces of work grows, however, another fact becomes hard to avoid. Slavery, in a way, was simply a contemporary institution that gave license to a subspecies of mankind that’s been around since we developed opposable thumbs: the bully, someone who sneers, taunts and abuses those not in a position to fight back.

Slavery may be out of fashion. Bullying is not. So that’s a subtext worth noting, though it should be stressed that the Roots producers don’t want our primary takeaway to be a greater dislike of bullies.

Roots focuses on a vile institution America permitted for 246 years, and the long path by which the descendants of one determined man finally threw off its shackles.

But slavery was a stone that still sends ripples to the wider shores of every American pond, and the fact we thought it was fine for all those centuries says some uncomfortable things about both the people of those times and the human nature that continues right up through today.

As for whether the new Roots matches the old one, that’s really a minor question. At a time when style too often trumps substance, Roots is a solid show about something that matters.

 
 
 
 
 
Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 
 Name (required)
 
 Email (required) (will not be published)
 
 Website (optional)
 
GOBLR
Type in the verification word shown on the image.