DAVID BIANCULLI

Founder / Editor

ERIC GOULD

Associate Editor

LINDA DONOVAN

Assistant Editor

Contributors

ALEX STRACHAN

MIKE HUGHES

KIM AKASS

MONIQUE NAZARETH

ROGER CATLIN

GARY EDGERTON

TOM BRINKMOELLER

GERALD JORDAN

NOEL HOLSTON

 
 
 
 
 
Smithsonian Channel Look Back on Charlie Hebdo Attack is Half Drawn
January 4, 2016  | By David Sicilia  | 11 comments
 


With the mid-November terrorist attacks in Paris and Saint-Denis still painfully fresh in our minds, it is worth reflecting on the terrorist attacks that opened 2015 in France – most notably the one at the satirical magazine 
Charlie Hebdo. This Thursday marks the one-year anniversary of what became a multi-event three-day siege. 

Smithsonian Channel’s “Paris Terror Attack: Charlie Hebdo”, airing tonight (Monday, January 4 at 8 p.m., ET) declines to reflect. It is a superficial look at these events that refuses to bring perspective, analysis, or even very good storytelling to one of the most important terrorist episodes in recent times. Smithsonian’s subcontractor, Films of Records, Ltd., and the program’s producer/director, Ursula Macfarlane, deserve special mention for doing such a poor job with such an important subject.

The basic facts were these: on January 7, 2015, the brothers Said and Chérif Kouachi, sponsored by Al-Qaeda’s branch in Yemen, massacred eleven Charlie Hebdo editors and cartoonists, a bodyguard and a janitor, wounded 11 others, then out on the street gunned down a (Muslim) French policeman, waved their assault weapons, and repeatedly shouted “We avenge the Prophet Mohammed” before speeding away. 

The documentary intercuts survivor interviews with stock news footage to tell that story and what followed in the next three days: the brothers’ trail going cold then hot again, the mass mobilization of French gendarmerie by land and air, the cornering of the suspects in an industrial building north of Paris, the final shootout. The film also weaves in a narrative about a second, coordinated assault, when a Kouachi accomplice named Coulibaly took 20 hostages in a kosher deli in Paris.

There are moving moments, from the pathos of victims reliving the horror to the texts that a Frenchman named Lilian sent as he hid under a sink in the room next to where the Kouachi brothers made their last stand.

Paris Terror Attack: Charlie Hebdo” skates by the collision between Western secular notions of free speech versus the sacrilege, for Muslims, of any visual depiction of Mohammed, much less one satirical or mocking. It fails to mention the 2011 jihadist attack on the magazine. It leaves out details of other terrorist attacks throughout France during the same three-day period. It offers virtually no expert analysis. It teaches us next to nothing about the magazine’s unique editorial stance, or about the terrorists’ backgrounds. 

In a revealing example of lazy editing, we hear a newscaster intone that the Hebdo attack “seems to be well thought out in advance.” But we’ve already learned that the Kouachi brothers initially burst into the wrong office, and that when they hijacked a second car, one of them accidentally left behind, of all things, his photo ID. Yet immediately following the “well thought out” clip, a police official tells us that the brothers were feeling pressured and hungry while on the lam because they only packed water and a couple of nutrition bars. So much for well-thought-out. 

The brothers’ last stand was pathetic. They were in contact with Coulibaly, who was trying to negotiate a shrewd deal, but then bolted to their deaths without exacting a single casualty. These are all revealing details, but we get no help making sense of them from the scriptwriters.

Several of the most important survivors (where’s Lilian?!) weren’t filmed. If it was their choice, it was a good one. But maybe their presence would have helped. It’s not that a look-back on the Charlie Hebdo attacks needs to be a brilliant exegesis on Islamic terrorism in contemporary France. But we are all hungry to understand, and the events of a year ago deserve more than a gloss. Smithsonian can do and has done much better. Next time it should hire a different production company.
 
 
 
 
 
Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 
 Name (required)
 
 Email (required) (will not be published)
 
NDYHH
Type in the verification word shown on the image.
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: 
11 Comments
 
 
Feed your reading obsession without emptying your wallet! Purchase popular novels at discounted prices and discover the joy of losing yourself in a good book. With incredible deals, your next literary journey is just a click away.
Mar 25, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Welcome to our shared book collection, where every book tells a story and every reader finds a connection. From bestsellers to hidden gems, there's a world of literature waiting to be explored. Come and join us in celebrating the joy of reading at the shared book collection.
Mar 20, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Great addition! Your post injected a fresh perspective into the conversation. I'm hooked and eagerly awaiting more insights from fellow forum members.
Mar 10, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Empower your online journey with our expertly crafted website, designed to help you compare hosting services effortlessly. Unravel the intricacies of different hosting plans and providers through our insightful reviews, ensuring your website's success in the competitive digital landscape.
Mar 2, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Navigate the digital landscape with confidence using our SEO optimisation solutions. Master the art of keyword targeting, content optimization, and link building to catapult your website to the top of search engine results. Drive organic traffic and establish your online dominance.
Feb 29, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Immerse yourself in the poetry of Monet's brushstrokes. Our monet canvas art collection showcases the iconic artist's mastery, bringing the allure of Impressionism to your home in a burst of color and light.
Feb 27, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Keep a detailed record of your sleeping pill usage to monitor patterns and discuss any concerns with your healthcare provider during follow-up appointments. Regular check-ins ensure that your sleep aid regimen remains appropriate, and necessary adjustments can be made for your continued well-being.
Feb 21, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Dive into this blog—it's a breath of fresh air! The writer's friendly tone makes it feel like a chat, not a lecture. Easy to read, easy to love, and packed with interesting facts.
Feb 9, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Empower your business with a captivating online presence through our custom website design Auburn Hills services. We strategically craft every element to enhance user experience, creating a seamless journey for your audience. Beyond aesthetics, our focus on functionality ensures your website not only impresses visually but also drives conversion rates, contributing to your overall business success.
Feb 7, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
Propel your brand forward with our tailored SEO solutions at social media marketing company in Pensacola. Experience the transformative power of higher search rankings, increased organic traffic, and a stronger online presence. Our strategic approach ensures your website stands out, attracting the right audience and converting visitors into loyal customers.
Feb 4, 2024   |  Reply
 
 
MICHAEL
CHARLIE HEBDO was a false flag staged event. Not surprising that they were planning to make this movie of the staged event to reinforce the fear instilled in people. 400 million dollars for the war on terror and increase of the surveillance police state. San Bernardino was also a false flag with Muslim patsies. Lets all give up our privacy and freedom for a police state terror.
Jan 5, 2016   |  Reply
 
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: