DAVID BIANCULLI

Founder / Editor

ERIC GOULD

Associate Editor

LINDA DONOVAN

Assistant Editor

Contributors

ALEX STRACHAN

MIKE HUGHES

KIM AKASS

MONIQUE NAZARETH

ROGER CATLIN

GARY EDGERTON

TOM BRINKMOELLER

GERALD JORDAN

NOEL HOLSTON

 
 
 
 
 
'Buried Treasure' - or Just More TV Junk?
August 25, 2011  | By Ronnie Gill  | 1 comment
 
Buried-Treasure-Leigh-Leslie-Keno.jpg

Wow! When I first heard about Fox's new Buried Treasure (Wednesdays at 8 p.m. ET), I thought: I'm going to love this show. It's Antiques Roadshow coming to houses like mine and justifying all those years of going to garage, church and yard sales. It's about everyday people picking up something for a dollar or a dime that is going to make them -- well, a millionaire.

Um, not quite.

Buried Treasure stars Leigh and Leslie Keno of PBS fame. The Keno brothers grew up surrounded by antiques -- their parents were both dealers -- and, according to them, have been fascinated by old objects since childhood. If you watch Roadshow, you will no doubt recognize them. They're those over-enthusiastic blond furniture appraisers who often get more excited about a "find" than its owner.

But rather than the mundane folks that people Roadshow, or even History Channel's Pawn Stars, the producers of Buried Treasure seem intent on upping the drama, and that means finding individuals who are sometimes as unusual and quirky as the objects they possess. The result? Something akin to a mashup of Roadshow and A&E's Hoarders.

Buried-Treasure-Kenos-Doering.jpg

The premiere opened with a mother and daughter from well-to-do Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y. Mom Liz Doering is living off the fumes of what daughter Lily describes, with some resentment, as "a lot of financial stability" that was squandered. Liz is also a hoarder who seems oblivious that the interior of her otherwise lovely home is a horror, piled high with her "stuff." She really loves her stuff and doesn't want to part with it. It is clear she could use professional counseling.

Her adult daughter wants the Kenos, whom she describes as "the rock stars of the antiques world," to find money in the mess that surrounds her mother. Lily, who has a 6-year-old daughter, complains that she buys the food and pays the bills and that "The answer to all our problems could be hiding under a sack of papers." Though shedding tears about how she wants to help Liz, Lily comes off as rather uncaring and coarse. Would a caring daughter expose her mother like this to her neighbors and community, not to mention the rest of the viewing world?

The Kenos "discover" five objects to take back to Manhattan to investigate further. Have they found Buried Treasure? We'll have to wait until the end of the show for the big reveal. It's a now commonplace TV reality technique that builds annoyance rather than suspense. (Note to the producers: People interested in a show about found objects don't need to be strung along to keep watching. Take a hint from Roadshow. Viewers get immediate gratification and are still watching after 14 years.)

Ultimately, all the items collected by the Kenos are valuable, including an ancient bronze Minoan bowl with a pre-auction value of $40,000 to $60,000. As the worth of each piece is announced, Lily jumps around and excitedly yells (bleeped) expletives, while Liz submissively agrees to let her treasures be sold. It is all rather sad to watch. I hated Lily and pitied Liz.

Buried-Treasure-Kenos-comic-book.jpg

Next comes Manhattan comic book artist Graig Weich and his wife, Liga. Graig is also a collector of comics, and the couple's cramped, claustrophobic one-bedroom apartment is overrun by that collection. Graig thinks it might be time to sell some of his stuff and move forward with his life. But like a lot of collectors, he has trouble letting go. Two normally highly valued comics he brings to the Keno's comic book experts turn out to be damaged. Graig decides not to sell his restored Incredible Hulk No. 1 (mint: $20,000) for $2,200, but parts with a repaired comic featuring the first appearance of Spider-Man (mint: $200,000) for $5,400. He is conflicted over an offer of $58,000 for a 1941 Superman animation cel by Max Fleischer.

When his wife tells him to keep it because she knows he'll regret selling it, he is so touched by her gesture he decides he now wants to part with it. Ultimately he leaves the decision to Liga, who convinces him to keep it. True love conquers all, apparently, including practicality. The collector in me understands how hard it is to sell off pieces, but the objective observer in me found it hard to understand why they wouldn't trade the windfall for better living conditions.

Finally, we return to Long Island, where Greenport winemaker Leslie Howard believes he might have inherited a valuable 17th century violin, left to him when his dad perished in a sailing accident when Howard was 12. The Kenos' experts, however, determine it is an early 20th century reproduction worth $300.

Along with the fabricated drama (including appraiser valuations getting cut at "the pre-auction value is" point before a commercial, a technique from HGTV's If Walls Could Talk), we wish the producers of Buried Treasure would dump the current voiceover announcer who explains what items are and their worth. We'd much prefer the Kenos do that in standup segments or do their own voiceovers.

Though I won't give up on the show yet, previews of coming episodes promise more hoarders, which makes me wary. Then again, it appears that one woman will get news that she owns something worth a million dollars.

And let's not forget that promo at the end of the show soliciting viewers to apply to have the Kenos examine a special item they might possess. There must be something in my attic . . .

5 Comments

Hi,
It was fun being on Buried Treasure.
Thanks for the write up. You can see my new comic book superheroes I created named Ravedactyl and Code Name: Justice at http://www.BeyondComics.TV & http://www.gekidolives.com
My best.

Comment posted on August 26, 2011 8:39 AM
Eileen said:

Love the Kenos, so I'll give this show a try. Living in Manhattan, there are stories galore about amazing finds curbside. Someone has died, or is moving, and things left for garbage pickup are picked up by a pedestrian on a lark. Later it turns out to be a very rare/valuable painting, etc. Gotta love that.

I do find Hoarders deeply disturbing on so many levels. I always feel badly when young kids are involved in this insanity. The hoarders are basically people who, prior to a hoarder intervention, truly need psychiatric help. Their homes are fire hazards, safety hazards and vermin infested. How they could possibly expect their children to live & EAT there is beyond the pale. I wonder how many visits from Children's Services have been authorized as a result of this show? I find it so sad I really can't watch. The last time I viewed it was two lovely teenage girls who hadn't seen the floor of their bedroom for years. And it wasn't for lack of their trying.

But, on an upside, Buried Treasure does sound fascinating. And I'll be rooting for some real finds.

Comment posted on August 28, 2011 12:07 PM
Christine said:

Buried Treasure had my curiosity peaked as I enjoy the Keno brothers on The Antiques Roadshow, however, the show could do with less drama. The expletives blurted out by the hoarder's daughter and the callous comments made by the comic book dealers could have been cut to lend the show some credibility.

Perhaps the Keno brothers should have more involvement in the production of the show to save their reputation.

I also believe the comic book dealers were snakes and tried to acquire valuable comics on the cheap. Glad Graig kept the cel!

Comment posted on August 31, 2011 9:59 PM

The idea of the show is great but all the created drama is just silly. Leading up to the price of an item than cutting to commercial and when you come back you repeat the same information already given and then give the price. The only way I will ever watch this show is after I have recorded it on my DVR and then I can fast forward through all of the nonsense, fabricated drama and the commercials.
The content of just one of your shows could be easilly condensed to half the time, therefore opening up time for more appraisals and more feel good stories.

Comment posted on August 31, 2011 11:19 PM
Miguel said:

The comic dealers were not snakes. When you are dealer you do not buy items at retail price. You purchase cheaper with the hopes of selling it for a profit. If your not going to make a profit why be in the business? Of course he might make more selling the cel himself to a collector, but that takes time, energy, and money. The prices offered on those two comics was more them I would have paid as a collector, because they were restored very badly. In comics, condition is king. I would rather have an unrestored beat up copy rather than a badly Frankenstein one.

Comment posted on September 1, 2011 3:37 PM
 
 
 
 
 
Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 
 Name (required)
 
 Email (required) (will not be published)
 
KXRAA
Type in the verification word shown on the image.
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: 
1 Comments
 
 
Iomaris vasquez
I have comic books I want to see how much they're worth can you help me
Dec 12, 2014   |  Reply
 
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: