DAVID BIANCULLI

Founder / Editor

ERIC GOULD

Associate Editor

LINDA DONOVAN

Assistant Editor

Contributors

ALEX STRACHAN

MIKE HUGHES

KIM AKASS

MONIQUE NAZARETH

ROGER CATLIN

GARY EDGERTON

TOM BRINKMOELLER

GERALD JORDAN

NOEL HOLSTON

 
 
 
 
 
NBC's 'Smash': A Musical Treat, A Dramatic Triumph... And a Gift
February 6, 2012  | By David Bianculli
 
smash-two-marilyns-at-mirro.jpg

There are lots of professional reasons I can give you to watch Monday's premiere of Smash, NBC's new drama series about the making of a Broadway musical -- starting with its creators, its cast, its premise, its clever twists, and its equally clever music and lyrics. But there's also a personal reason, which I'll save for last...

But for starters, there's the very first, utterly perfect opening scene of Smash, which premieres Monday at 10 p.m. ET on NBC.

smash-somewhere-over-the-ra.jpg

Katharine McPhee, playing wannabe Broadway singer Karen Cartwright, is singing -- in a solo spotlight, presumably on stage -- the opening lines of "Over the Rainbow." It's a beautiful moment, a beautiful voice, and it leaves you spellbound.

Until, that is, the spell is broken, unexpectedly and jarringly, by the sound of a cell phone.

Suddenly, the comforting, embracing semi-darkness is replaced by the harsh, unforgiving light of an audition room -- and the harsher, even less forgiving, dismissive look of the casting director who has interrupted the audition's flow, and darkened Karen's rainbow, by answering a cell phone.

So not long after Karen sings "Dreams that you dare to dream really do come true," she's been thanked, dismissed, and ushered out the door. Ouch.

Next up: a veteran Broadway chorus member named Ivy Lynn, played by Megan Hilty, who enters with lots of attitude, confidence, and cleavage.

Instantly, we have a battle on our hands -- and a wonderful new show at our doorstep.

Theresa Rebeck, whose resume includes credits from both Broadway (the current Seminar) and TV (as a writer on, among other series, NYPD Blue, Brooklyn Bridge and Dream On), is playful enough -- and smart enough -- to steep Smash in various levels of subtext and homage.

McPhee-Idol.jpg

That opening song choice, I suspect, was no accident. Not only is it Judy Garland's signature number, but "Over the Rainbow" also was a song sung by McPhee when she was one of the two finalists on Season 5 of American Idol -- the season, and the show, in which she lost, ultimately, to Taylor Hicks.

That was in 2006. Now, six years later, to launch Smash, she's singing the same song -- and, at the very start of her new prime-time TV showcase, having the rug pulled out from under her just as brutally. So you really, really root for her Karen character, right from the start.

Except that Megan Hilty, who enters next and struts her stuff as Ivy, has an endearing Broadway baby story as well: being one of the replacement Glindas in Wicked, then starring as Doralee (the Dolly Parton part) in Broadway's 9 to 5: The Musical. So she has her backstory, and her fans, as well. And when the two of them get callbacks for a proposed new musical, on the life of Marilyn Monroe, there are reasons to root for both.

But if you're expecting a mere musical showdown -- a Team Karen vs. Team Ivy sort of thing -- Smash is much more ambitious than that. It won't take very long before the leading role of Marilyn is awarded, but that's only the beginning of the workshops, the drama, and the surprise twists and turns.

Smash, which was conceived as an idea by Steven Spielberg, begins with a very high ambition: Explore and dramatize, in a scripted weekly TV series, the act of creating a musical. As TV concepts go, it sounds simple. But in practice, it's about as simple as filming a story about a killer shark -- in the days before CGI.

smash-marilyn-musical-fanta.jpg

One of the best conceits about Smash is that when the singers are singing songs from the proposed Marilyn musical, or when the composers are watching the dancers and singers go through their initial paces, their imagination kicks in, and we cut between the reality of the rehearsal and the fantasies of the performers and onlookers.

It's not a finished product -- not what the eventual Broadway show will turn out to be, should it turn out at all -- but it's heightened from the rehearsal "reality," so we see costumes, and better lighting, and even a few stage props and scenery elements. And to do that, these songs not only have to be written, and choreographed, but performed twice, in both rough and slick versions.

This requires the actual creative team members to be several steps ahead of their on-screen counterparts. Michael Mayer has directed the pilot, and Joshua Bergasse has choreographed the numbers, long before Jack Davenport gets to play Derek Wills, the tyrannical director-choreographer.

smash-songwriters.jpg

Similarly, songwriters Marc Shaiman and Scott Wittman (Hairspray) have to come up with the music and lyrics for a Marilyn musical, so we can watch as the fictional composers on Smash -- Debra Messing as Julia Houston and Christian Borle as Tom Levitt -- can do the same. And as the producer, we have the delightful Anjelica Huston as Eileen Rand, one of many nuanced, driven characters surrounding the musical within this musical drama.

It's all very much a let's-put-on-a-show story, with as much emphasis on the hardships of raising money in a tight economy, and on the sexual and other volatile shenanigans in and around a Broadway company, as on the production itself. But the creative process is vey much front and center, too -- not only how things are done, but why.

In these respects, Smash is much closer to a modern remake of Gold Diggers of 1933 than an instant rehash of Glee. It's also canny and tasteful enough to make New York City as much a character in Smash as it is in Law & Order.

When a character on Smash walks under the awning of Sardi's, or is enveloped by Times Square, you know you're not on the backlot of Hollywood somewhere. And that verisimilitude, no less than the writing, direction, music and performances, makes Smash crackle with energy.

I've previewed four episodes of Smash, enough to know it really knows what it's doing and where it's going. It wouldn't surprise me at all if, in 2013, there were a real, full-length Marilyn: The Musical either on our TV sets, or on Broadway.

It especially wouldn't surprise me since two of the executive producers of Smash are Neil Meron and Craig Zadan, whose credits include the current Broadway revival of How to Succeed in Business without Really Trying, the Oscar-winning film version of Chicago, and a string of excellent musicals mounted for TV, starting with Bette Midler in Gypsy.

(To hear my recent interview with Meron and Zadan on NPR's Fresh Air with Terry Gross, click HERE.)

There are enough soap opera elements in Smash -- a divorce proceeding here, a baby adoption there, unsupportive parents over there -- to make it sort of a TV hybrid: part musical, part making-of-a-musical, part soapy drama. And, in the hands of these particular artists, all the elements work.

Smash-Katherine-McPhee-Mega.jpg

McPhee is a much better actress than her credits would suggest, Hilty captures Marilyn's breathy singing voice with spooky precision, and Messing and Huston run away with every scene in which they appear. There are fine male performances here, too, but Smash belongs to the women.

Oh, and finally -- the personal reason for me loving Smash so much? In high school, I was part of a performing arts troupe at Ft. Lauderdale's Nova High School -- very Glee-ish, except we mounted musicals and variety shows. And, except for one horrific exception, I was backstage all the way, as a lighting designer and stage manager.

But the start-to-finish process of putting on a show -- I never forgot that, and never lost sight of what a joy, and a rarity, it is to create something out of nothing. And, when it's such a collaborative effort and it all comes together, what a gift that is.

So take it from me: Smash is a gift.

4 Comments

Len F. said:

Please tell us that horrific exception...your readers want to know!!

[Let's just say that "horrific exception" involved me being flanked by two beautiful young women while carrying a ridiculously heavy flag as George M. Cohan, singing the world's most precarious version of "Yankee Doodle Dandy." And gee, Len, thanks for asking, he says sarcastically. - DB]

Comment posted on February 6, 2012 10:55 AM
Ben said:

I'm a theatrical Lighting Designer, and I had a huge grin on my face throughout the pilot. It reminded me why I love what I do and what I do it for. I feel like I know these people, well, because I've met people just like them before. This show deserves to succeed, not only because it's damn good, but because people out there should know what we put ourselves though for art - how hard it is, and how worthwhile it ends up being. I've been shouting from the rooftops at everyone I know to watch this show. Let it be a Smash hit indeed!

[Dear Ben -- So glad to hear you liked it. I have a mission for you, Ben, should you decide to accept it. Will you keep watching for a few more weeks, then write us a small review from your very informed perspective? We're about to introduce a new feature, where readers with occupations relevant to certain shows get to weigh in on those shows -- and it'd be great to have you in the initial batch. - DB]

Comment posted on February 6, 2012 9:18 PM
Ben said:

David,

It would be my pleasure to write you a review from my perspective. It's been very interesting to hear the reactions from my colleagues who've seen the Pilot and I'd love to throw my hat in the ring with my take on the series after it has progressed a bit.

[Thanks! Have your people contact my people! We're on! -- DB]

Comment posted on February 7, 2012 10:54 PM
Anthony said:

It's like saying the literary classics are culturally irrelevant because they aren't on the NY Times best-seller list. I don't believe the BoM Musical is destined to become a classic, but the parallel still holds. But, whatever...

Comment posted on February 21, 2012 9:22 PM
 
 
 
 
 
Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 
 Name (required)
 
 Email (required) (will not be published)
 
EYIRP
Type in the verification word shown on the image.