DAVID BIANCULLI

Founder / Editor

ERIC GOULD

Associate Editor

LINDA DONOVAN

Assistant Editor

Contributors

ALEX STRACHAN

MIKE HUGHES

KIM AKASS

MONIQUE NAZARETH

ROGER CATLIN

GARY EDGERTON

TOM BRINKMOELLER

GERALD JORDAN

NOEL HOLSTON

 
 
 
 
 
Syfy's 'Defiance' Engaging on Multiple Levels
April 14, 2013  | By Ed Bark  | 2 comments
 

Editor's Note: For a behind-the-scenes look at the Defiance set, see Ed Martin's TV Mix.


The ripping good special effects of Syfy’s Defiance harken to Fox’s recently failed and likewise futuristic Terra Nova, which also popped the eyes.

In each case, the bigger your DVD screen, the better. Another shared trait: the scripts and story lines tend to be cliche-heavy and sense-dulling predictable.

But Defiance, premiering Monday, April 15 at 9 p.m. ET with a two-hour episode, is decidedly different in one new worldly respect. Syfy, owned by NBC Universal, is touting it as a “transmedia event” being launched “as both an original series and a multi-platform video game … Each week viewers will follow an immersive character drama set in the boom-town of Defiance, which sits atop the ruins of St. Louis, while in the game, players will experience the new frontier of the San Francisco Bay area.”

Furthermore, “events in the show will impact the game, and events in the game will impact the show, creating an unprecedented interactive storytelling experience,” according to Syfy publicity materials.

Frankly, that sounds like a little too much work. But go for it if you’d like while these spaces stick to a review of just the show.

Here are the basics. A huge incursion of seven different alien races led to a “Terraformed Earth” 33 years into the future. All-out war has left a lot of devastation. But in Defiance, formerly St. Louis, the famed arch remains while various groups of aliens and humans strive to live peaceably. Alas, they’re also subject to periodic attacks by vicious outside forces.

Viewers are first introduced to former Marine and latter day “tracker” Joshua Nolan (Grant Bowler, far left from Lifetime’s recent Liz & Dick) and his fiery adopted daughter, Irisa (Stephanie Leonidas, left). She’s an Irathient by birth, and they often don’t get along very well. Still, dad and daughter manage to act in perfect harmony during a spirited and quite prolonged sing-along to Johnny Cash’s “Jackson.” It’s their road music for a salvage mission that yields a blue, glowing ball. It looks like a thrift store castoff but supposedly is worth millions. And this time Joshua promises to parlay any riches into Irisa’s dream trip to the promised land of Antarctica, which she has seen only in a postcard book.

Meanwhile, Defiance is being run by new mayor Amanda Rosewater (Julie Benz, right), who delivers what’s supposed to be a stirring speech (but isn’t) on Armistice Day. The scheming Albino-like Castithan couple of Datak and Stahma Tarr (Tony Curran, Jaime Murray, below left) are in attendance, as is grumpy mining magnate Rafe McCawley (Graham Greene). Another central character, Amanda’s sister, Kenya (Mia Kirshner), runs the NeedWant bar and brothel.

Rafe’s rebellious daughter, Christie (Nicole Munoz), wants to marry the Tarrs’ son, Alak (Jesse Rath). Friction ensues between the families while Defiance also girds for a major invasion by the bad-nasty Volges. Will Joshua stick around to help out after the mayor delivers a paint-by-the-numbers pep talk to the citizenry? Might he end up being the town’s new “Lawkeeper?” You already know those answers.

Bowler tries hard to be a jaunty, glib Joshua, but the script does him no favors. And the way he says “Yeahhhh” Sunday night is very reminiscent of Gary Cole’s delivery of that word as the unyielding bossman of Office Space.

But the mayor and Greene’s Rafe get stuck with most of the clunkier lines. In next week’s Episode 2, hear the old man bellow, “If you walk out that door again, there’s no coming back.” And later: “Predicting the future’s a sucker’s game.” Viewers also will learn that Rafe’s dad was “Chow Down Brown,” a prosperous dog food merchandiser. It’s downright painful when Joshua sings the company’s jingle while Rafe grouses some more.

But at least Irisa, also known as “Little Wolf,” emerges as a standout character in the three episodes sent for review. And the Tarrs can be some fun with their quirky ways and villainous sneers. Wife Stahma also rocks some outfits that would be even too abbreviated for Dancing with the Stars.

All the while, Defiance certainly doesn’t look cheap. The big battle climaxing Episode 1 is pretty much a wowser. Landscapes are breathtaking throughout and those big bad “Hellbugs” in Episode 3 are also impressively rendered. The accompanying, frequently deployed mood music doesn’t fare nearly so well. Particularly a lengthy “Ooh, ooh child, things are gonna get easier” tableau at the end of Episode 3. It’s one big “Please stop!” groaner.

Defiance is definitely a treat for the eyes, though, if not always the ears. It’s good to see a cable network aspiring to do something big and bold rather than again dipping into America’s seemingly bottomless pit of “real-life” hillbillies, bumpkins and big-bearded non-bathers. So thanks for that, Syfy. Now please get to work on the basics.

GRADE:C+
 
Read more by Ed Bark at unclebarky.com

 
 
 
 
 
Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 
 Name (required)
 
 Email (required) (will not be published)
 
ORJEG
Type in the verification word shown on the image.
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: 
2 Comments
 
 
Brian Greene
Well, Barky you must not be much of a science fiction fan! This show is a breath of fresh air in a genre that doesn't get nearly enough attention. The song at the end, done by Beth Orton is the most beautiful cover of the tune I have ever heard, so it's a big poop sandwich for the Barkster that you have no soul! It's real music Barky, not Hip Hop or bubble gum, get over it and open your little mind.
May 12, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
Frank Dracman
I came, I saw, I gave up before the end of Episode 1. I really would have liked a prelude episode that showed how Earth got the way it ended up in this story. Where did all the crazy wildlife come from? Was the unrecognizable foliage a result of "terraforming"? I may be wrong but it doesn't seem probable or een scientifically possible for so many changes to occur in just 33 years.
And yes the dialogue is, to me, abysmal. If the show has smart dialogue and engaging characters, I can forgive most everything else. This just didn't.
Apr 21, 2013   |  Reply
 
 
 
 Page: 1 of 1  | Go to page: