TV Worth Watching Blog

Forget "American Idol" -- British Idol is "Doctor Who"


The fourth season of the current incarnation of Doctor Who ends tonight at 8:30 p.m. ET on Sci Fi Channel -- but whatever audience it attracts will be the merest fraction of what it drew when shown recently in the United Kingdom.

It drew a 47 percent share of viewers watching TV at that hour, which are Super Bowl numbers here in the States. The last American Idol finale, by comparison, claimed an audience share in the low 30s. Doctor Who, in England, is likely to end the year as that nation's most-viewed entertainment program.

Over here, the question may be less "Doctor Who"? -- and more "Doctor Why"?

Doctor_Gunfighters.jpg

In the U.K., Doctor Who was launched in 1963, in the aftermath of the John F. Kennedy assassination. Its first big villains were slow-talking robots named The Daleks, and the Doctor was played by William Hartnell, who portrayed a Time Lord capable of traveling through time and space. He also had the gift of regeneration, with which he could, at the moment of death, metamorphose into someone who looked and sounded completely different.

Time Lords, according to that early mythology, could regenerate a dozen times. When Doctor Who was launched, that arbitrary figure may as well have been 100 -- though it came in handy in 1966, when Hartnell was replaced by Patrick Troughton, becoming the "second" Doctor Who.

doctor-who-tennant.jpg

But 45 years later, with the show still running, current series star David Tennant is, by most counts, the 10th Doctor, and tonight's finale leads the way for him, too, to exit the show, after a series of quarterly specials in 2009. After he's replaced, the last Time Lord should have one life left.

doctor-who-june-06.jpg

Though, already, he's given life to such spinoffs as Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures, and could well spawn another with lovely Georgia Moffett as the doctor's cloned daughter.

doctor-who-parallel-worlds.jpg

What's so much fun about this fourth-season finale is how it presents itself as a big deal to fans. Billie Piper, who played the Doctor's assistant Rose before moving on to Secret Diary of a Call Girl, is back. So is another former assistant, Freema Agyeman's Dr. Martha Jones. And John Barrowman's Captain Jack Harkness, now starring in Torchwood. And Elisabeth Sladen, now a grown-up former assistant to a former doctor, starring in The Sarah Jane Adventures.

What fun. And yet, series writer-producer Russell T. Davies, who has run and revitalized the show for four seasons now, has been brilliant this year at mixing the silly sci-fi fun with actual scares and dramatic scenes. His plots, and his characters, have depth.

doctor_who_finale_scene.jpg

And in a show with time at its center, he's very mindful and respectful of history: The big villains in the finale are the Daleks and their evil creator, Davros, updated versions of the Big Bads from the time of the LBJ administration.

When almost half a country's TV sets in use are tuned to the same thing, you know some chord is being struck. Watch Doctor Who tonight, and try to figure out why...

4 Comments

Avi said:

I've become such a huge fan of Doctor Who within the past 2 years. The idea of such a long running show in the UK is really what originally made me look into it furthur. For me, what makes me keep coming back for more is the depth of the Doctor. A normal science fiction character is simple and usually has to choose between shooting and killing a character or not. But Doctor who is different. He doesn't use guns. He wants everyone to live happily, yet everywhere he goes, there is death. But what really makes him the most interesting to me is his fascination with humans. To him, humans are the best and at times the worst creatures in the universe. For me, Doctor Who is about the hope and the potential of humanity, despite our obvious flaws.

Comment posted on August 1, 2008 9:38 AM

I was under the impression that Tennant had already agreed to portray the Doctor for the 2010 season. No?

Love the site, by the way, and I'm looking forward to your reviews of the various Fall series.

Comment posted on August 1, 2008 10:03 AM
Henri said:

Prior to the new series (in 2005) I had never watched Dr Who. I think the best TV advice I've taken was to make it through the first 4 episodes of "Season 1" (with Christopher Eccleston as the 9th Doctor). Been hooked ever since.

This episode was a great season finale! I'd recommend watching the "Dr Who Confidential" behind-the-scenes episode after watching the finale (only available via Bittorrent to those of us in the USA I believe)

now we have to wait till 2010 for season 5 I believe :(

Comment posted on August 1, 2008 12:51 PM
anchorgirl said:

I adore the new(ish) Doctor Who. I'd enjoyed it when Tom Baker and Peter Davison were in it, but wasn't exactly a devotee. At the urging of a fanboy coworker, I checked out season 1, and was hooked. The hook was good and truly set when Tennant became the 10th Doctor.

Comment posted on August 3, 2008 10:55 PM

Leave a comment





David Bianculli

Behind David in the picture is the first TV owned by his father, Virgil Bianculli, a 1946 Raytheon. (The TV, not his father. His father was a 1923 Italian.)

David Bianculli has been a TV critic since 1975, including a 14-year stint at the New York Daily News, and sees no reason to stop now. Currently, he's TV critic for NPR's Fresh Air, occasional substitute host for that show's Terry Gross, and teaches TV and film history at New Jersey's Rowan University. His most recent book is 2009's Dangerously Funny: The Uncensored Story of 'The Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour,' and he's at work on another.

DAVID BIANCULLI
Founder / Editor

DIANE WERTS
Managing Editor

CONTRIBUTORS

NOEL HOLSTON
  The Grassy Noel

ERIC GOULD
  The Cold Light Reader

THERESA CORIGLIANO
  Terri TV

 

ED BARK
  Uncle Barky's Bytes

DAVID SICILIA
  TV Moneyland

BILL BRIOUX
  TV Feeds My Family

ALAN PERGAMENT
  Still TalkinTV

JANE BOURSAW
  Reel Life with Jane

TOM BRINKMOELLER
  Raised on MTM

ED MARTIN
  Ed Martin's TV Mix

GERALD JORDAN
  Crossing Jordan

MIKE DONOVAN
  Thinking Inside the Box

P.J. BEDNARSKI
  I Like to Watch

ERIC MINK
  Tiny Tin Voice

RONNIE GILL
  Altered Reality

MARK BIANCULLI
  The Son Also Criticizes

DIANE HOLLOWAY
  Holloway's Couch



Get TV Worth Watching Direct

Sign up for a
FREE subscription
for TVWW updates




More TV

FIND A TV FACT

LATEST TV NEWS

SMART CRITICS

BACKSTAGE BLOGS

STREAMING VIDEO

CHANNEL SITES

TV FUN/EPHEMERA

OTHER STUFF

HAVE YOU READ THIS YET?