Serving newspaper readers since 1975... "Fresh Air" listeners since 1985...Rowan University students since 1998... Online visitors since 2007...
Emmy Nominations Are Out, "Mad Men" Is In, and "Friday Night Lights" Was Robbed
Nominations for the 2008 Primetime Emmy Awards were announced this morning, and the verdicts are clear. AMC is latest cable-network darling to catch the eye of the voters, with Mad Men getting more than twice as many nominations as any other drama series, and with Breaking Bad being noticed, too.
Meanwhile, NBC's Friday Night Lights was, in a word, robbed.
The family drama series, in its second season, was given just a single nomination, for Outstanding Casting for a Drama Series. Yet if the cast is so outstanding -- and it is -- how in the world do you ignore the work of the show's brilliant stars, Kyle Chandler and Connie Britton? You shouldn't. But the Emmy voters did.
Why? I suspect, in part, because of a long-standing, simmering, but wholly unnecessary inferiority complex. When Emmy voters are confronted with too many talented actors or actresses in a given category, movie stars always seem to be favored over stars from TV itself.
In the Lead Actress in a Drama Series category, for example, Glenn Close from Damages and Kyra Sedgwick from The Closer ae movie stars who deserved their nomination, but did Holly Hunter of Saving Grace, or even Sally Field of Brothers & Sisters, given the other possibilities? Especially since Connie Britton was overlooked?
And while the Lead Actor in a Drama category is loaded with perhaps the strongest field in the race this year -- Michael C. Hall from Dexter, Hugh Laurie from House, James Spader from Boston Legal, and category newcomers Jon Hamm from Mad Men, Bryan Cranston from Breaking Bad and Gabriel Byrne from In Treatment -- Kyle Chandler really, really deserved to be in there.
Other shifts, spurns and surprises?
The Wire, in its final year, was dismissed again, given only one nomination, for the script for the finale. Rescue Me got nods only for cinematography and guest actor Charles Durning -- even though Denis Leary is another actor deserving of a best-actor nod. And David Duchovny from Californication didn't get a comedy Lead Actor nod, even though Charlie Sheen from Two and a Half Men did.
Where are Minnie Driver and Eddie Izzard from The Riches? How in the world did Ken Burns' The War fall through the cracks, nominated as neither Outstanding Nonfiction Special nor Outstanding Nonfiction Series. Clearly, it was one or the other, so where is it? And how and why did Desperate Housewives fall so far out of favor? It had a very strong year, yet drew performing-category nominations only for guest actresses Polly Bergen and Kathryn Joosten.
The same category, though, did make room for Edie Falco, Elaine Stritch and Carrie Fisher, all from 30 Rock. And while Alec Baldwin has been nominated before for that show, as he was again this year, this year he absolutely deserves to win.
Then again, so does Kyle Chandler, and he's not even in the running...
4 Comments
Leave a comment
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
DAVID BIANCULLI
Founder / Editor
DIANE WERTS
Managing Editor
CONTRIBUTORS
ED BARK
Uncle Barky's Bytes
P.J. BEDNARSKI
I Like to Watch
MARK BIANCULLI
The Son Also Criticizes
TOM BRINKMOELLER
Raised on MTM
BILL BRIOUX
TV Feeds My Family
THERESA CORIGLIANO
Terri TV
ERIC GOULD
The Cold Light Reader
DIANE HOLLOWAY
Holloway's Couch
NOEL HOLSTON
The Grassy Noel
GERALD JORDAN
Crossing Jordan
ED MARTIN
Ed Martin's TV Mix
ERIC MINK
Tiny Tin Voice
ALAN PERGAMENT
Still TalkinTV
Sign up for a
FREE subscription
for TVWW updates
I don't watch Friday Night Lights, so I can't comment on that, but I'm very happy to see that Michael C. Hall was nominated for Dexter. I love the show and he just does the creepy, insane serial killer part so well. MCH is a great actor and totally deserves the Emmy, not just the nomination.
I agree with you completely regarding the many oversights in the Emmy nominations. While some nominations pleased me -- I love Mad Men, Dexter, The Office and 30 Rock -- I was disappointed by snubbing of Kyle Chandler, Connie Britton, Eddie Izzard, Minnie Driver, any of the amazingly talented actors from The Wire, and David Duchovny (who imparts such pathos into a character I would generally loathe). I was also disappointed that Amy Ryan wasn't recognized for her guest starring spot in the season finale of The Office. I thought her character and performance fit in flawlessly with the ensemble cast.
I'm delighted that the wonderful Alec Baldwin was again recognized for his brilliant work on 30 Rock, and I truly hope this is his year to win.
More importantly (to me, that is) is the terrific Bryan Cranston getting a nod for Breaking Bad. It's almost ironic he gets nominated for Drama when year in and year out on Malcolm in the Middle he was hilarious, yet never took home an Emmy. That always bothered me, but now there is justice for the delightful Mr. Cranston. As much as I love Mad Men, I'd love to see Bryan win.
The emmy's became irrelevant to me when the snubbed Friday Night Lights last year. Their choices for nominations and as a result, who wins the awards, mean absolutely nothing to me anymore. The voters continuously choose the actors with the biggest names and the same nominees year after year.