Serving newspaper readers since 1975... "Fresh Air" listeners since 1985...Rowan University students since 1998... Online visitors since 2007...
March 13, 2008 - ABC's "Lost" Is Great, But Its "Enhanced Lost" Is Grating
The writers' strike may explain it, but doesn't excuse it. The "enhanced" hour of Lost that precedes tonight's new hour of Lost is even worse than a week-old rerun.
It's a week-old rerun that doesn't add to the viewing experience. It detracts from it.
Let's be clear about this. A fresh episode of Lost, such as the one shown tonight at 9 ET, is one of broadcast TV's crown jewels. It's one of the best-written, most ambitious dramatic series on television, and a new episode is a highlight of any discerning viewer's week. So I love Lost. Make no mistake about that.
But for a month now, ABC has been leading into each week's new Lost by repeating last week's episode. Not just repeating it, but peppering it with subtitled notes, as if it were a episode of Pop-Up Videos.
Some of the things it points out are laughably, irritatingly obvious. Others are astoundingly, irritatingly arcane and obtuse - the sort of references not even Dennis Miller would get, much less craft a joke around.
But here's the thing. Lost is so visually dense already, it doesn't need the footnote equivalent of a news crawl to keep viewers from being bored. Calling the bottom-third messages an "enhanced" episode of Lost is a heinous misuse of language.
It's more like a "defaced" episode - and it's a waste of an hour on ABC.
These days, though, that's not so unusual an occurrence.
2 Comments
Leave a comment
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
DAVID BIANCULLI
Founder / Editor
DIANE WERTS
Managing Editor
CONTRIBUTORS
ED BARK
Uncle Barky's Bytes
P.J. BEDNARSKI
I Like to Watch
MARK BIANCULLI
The Son Also Criticizes
TOM BRINKMOELLER
Raised on MTM
BILL BRIOUX
TV Feeds My Family
THERESA CORIGLIANO
Terri TV
ERIC GOULD
The Cold Light Reader
DIANE HOLLOWAY
Holloway's Couch
NOEL HOLSTON
The Grassy Noel
GERALD JORDAN
Crossing Jordan
ED MARTIN
Ed Martin's TV Mix
ERIC MINK
Tiny Tin Voice
ALAN PERGAMENT
Still TalkinTV
Sign up for a
FREE subscription
for TVWW updates
Long time blog reader, first time posting a 90% rejection of a blog commentary (without spellcheck on my blackberry-no not iphone b/c verizon isn't at&t).
Right off the bat, I concede the fact that lost is visually dense and it challenges the viewer to keep up, if they try to watch the show and read at the same time(that's the 10%). Given that, here's my perspective:
1) It is a re-run, so who cares what abc cares to show instead of another reality show like 'My dog beat up your Dad'
2) Jerry Garcia compared Deadheads to people's taste in licorice: '...not everyone likes it, but the ones who do like it REALLY like it'. While my t-shirt with the quote is long gone, it still can be applied to lost fans...let us have our licorice!
3) The enhanced episodes do not set off tivos/dvrs to think it is a new episode...haven't enhanced episodes of other shows done that, even when the extra is a scene with gene simmons harrassing ivanka trump? So give credit to the lost producers (gotta love damon and carlton) to not pass off used goods as new.
You dig? Btw, I love the blog!
Thank god this isn't another press release including stock phrases of praise for the enhanced, or as I like to call it, stupid bar.
The inclusion of this information bar at the bottom of rerun episodes is similar to being given the answers to a crossword puzzle. It isn't fun if you don't work for it.
It is a shame to trivialize the importance of observation. It undermines the dramatic potential of television. Commentary for a fictional drama is a cheap gimmick that may briefly capture the attention of fair weather viewers but hardly maintain them.
If the producers of Lost haven't figured out by now that their target audience loves to rely on their own memory then the show is in deep, stupid, trouble.