March 10, 2008 - When Is It Fair, and Unfair, to Reveal TV Secrets?: Two Case Studies
I've written plenty about the final episode of The Wire, the excellent David Simon drama that concluded last night - but was careful not to reveal any secrets or discuss the ending. Now that it's been televised, is it fair game? Or is there still a "I've recorded it, but haven't seen it" faction in play?
And what's the point of honoring secrets anyway, if the networks don't?
Start with The Wire. Here's my position on "spoilers": A well-written preview shouldn't reveal anything that would detract from the audience's enjoyment. Once the program is televised, though, all analysis and details are fair game. If you're a Wire fan, and still have the finale put aside somewhere to watch, then put the rest of this column in the same "futures" pile. I refuse to wait.
My favorite elements of the finale? Mayor Carcetti, all but popping a blood vessel when he learns of the serial-killer scam. Drug-dealer Marlo, so disheartened by going "straight" that he heads straight from the penthouse to the street to confront, and survive, some armed punks. Gus, flashing one last knowing semi-smile from the depths of the copy desk.
And most of all, Bubbles, the heart and soul of the show, finally being allowed to ascend the basement stairs of his sister's home and join them at the kitchen table. At least the newspaper, by profiling Bubbles and changing his sister's opinion of him, did one thing right.
Saddest element? The duplicitous reporter winning the Pulitzer, and the traffic and skyline shots showing the distancing speed and disheartening disparity of city life. The Wire didn't end up offering many solutions. Salute it, though, for shining white-hot spotlights on the endemic, complicated problems.
Now for the flip side of my "fair game" argument. I had forgotten to record The Celebrity Apprentice on NBC Thursday, so I caught a rerun on CNBC a few days later. It was the episode culminating in a terrific, heated showdown between Piers Morgan and Omarosa - and before we found out her fate on the program, it was revealed on a commercial-break promo for the following week's NBC episode.
There was Omarosa with a red circle and slash across her face, and the promise that the next Apprentice would be "Omarosa-free." And now, back to our program. Guess who gets fired?
According to my own "spoiler" position, I guess I can't get too incensed about this. NBC, after all, televised the episode already. But if the only reason to rerun the episode on CNBC is to pick up viewers who didn't watch on NBC, shouldn't that climax-revealing promo have been delayed until the end of the episode, as I'm sure it was on NBC?
Why should critics play fair, if the networks won't?
4 Comments
Leave a comment
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
DAVID BIANCULLI
Founder / Editor
DIANE WERTS
Managing Editor
CONTRIBUTORS
ED MARTIN
Ed Martin's TV Mix
ED BARK
Uncle Barky's Bytes
NOEL HOLSTON
The Grassy Noel
ERIC GOULD
The Cold Light Reader
THERESA CORIGLIANO
Terri TV
DAVID SICILIA
TV Moneyland
BILL BRIOUX
TV Feeds My Family
ALAN PERGAMENT
Still TalkinTV
JANE BOURSAW
Reel Life with Jane
TOM BRINKMOELLER
Raised on MTM
GERALD JORDAN
Crossing Jordan
MIKE DONOVAN
Thinking Inside the Box
P.J. BEDNARSKI
I Like to Watch
ERIC MINK
Tiny Tin Voice
RONNIE GILL
Altered Reality
MARK BIANCULLI
The Son Also Criticizes
DIANE HOLLOWAY
Holloway's Couch
Sign up for a
FREE subscription
for TVWW updates

Since I had to work Sunday night, and then get up and head straight back out Monday, I studiously avoided any media that would give me any clues to how "The Wire" ended. I work in news, and expected to see something slugged "The Wire Finale" on the wires, as I did -- and avoided -- when "The Sopranos" ended (sort of). Instead, there was nothing; are my tastes that non-mainstream? (Umm...yeah.) For some reason, Omar's snuffing made the wires, but I managed to dodge that bullet, so to speak.
So whether you offered a spoiler or not, as swell as this blog might be, I wasn't bitin'. And as for "The Apprentice" -- is that show STILL on?!?
By the way, I found "The Wire" finale incredibly satisfying: Michael takes up Omar's mantle; Bunk and Kima (sp?) find their Murder Police Partners groove; Jay gives Jimmy an appropriately vulgar send-off; Bubbs is accepted as a human by his sister (which I hope means poor Duqwan (again, sp?) has redemption in his future; Gus still has a gig; yeah, that weasel wins a Pulitzer but he'll end up like Margaret B. Smith in the end; Marlo's thrill-seeker gene's gonna get him got; and Jimmy (who never got the accent right) does the right thing. Oh, and Lester goes back to makin' miniatures and whoopie with his first-season former pole-dancer squeeze.
Now, if they could only cook up an really fab "Deadwood" finale...or maybe a full final season. Hey, a girl can dream.
Oh, and perhaps the most satisfying thing about the last season of "The Wire": The real Fran who inspired the character on "The Corner" was the phlebotomist who drew Bubbs's blood for his HIV test.
Nice post, David, at least as far as I could tell from the paragraphs I read. I'm still catching up on "The Wire" so I had to skip a few. Obviously the CNBC flub was just an oversight. They probably didn't have a suitably ambiguous promo to run in its place. Tight budgets and all. In any case, if your readers are interested in listening, there's a recent episode (3/07) of Shifting Channels -- a fairly new podcast -- that covers the whole landmine-filled landscape of spoilers -- avoiding them and seeking them out. It's at www.shiftingchannels.com.
Although I don't watch The Wire (i know, i know) I do agree that spoilers aren't spoilers anymore after an episode has aired--and this is from someone who watches virtually nothing "live" anymore. Once I DVR it, its up to me when I want to watch it, and I can't expect you to wait for me forever! lol
As for The Apprentice, that sort of promo has been a pet peeve of mine for a while. Bravo loves to do that during weekend re-runs of Top Chef or Project Runway, revealing who was ousted that episode *while they're re-running it*! It's such a pain in the neck. If you're actually watching the re-run, it means probably either a) you're a fan who forgot to DVR it, b), you're a fan who doesnt own a DVR. Either way, why would you want to know what happens before you see it?!